AS | Ankit Sarawagi|Founder, CFOmatrix·September 2026·9 min read | Fundraising |
When a private company wants to issue fresh shares, it has two main legal routes, and founders often pick the wrong mental model. A rights issue is the simpler one on paper, but the moment a new investor is putting money in, the law forces you down the private placement road, with its offer letter, valuation, separate bank account and a 15-day filing clock.
Both routes issue new Equity Shares and both raise fresh capital for the company, but they answer completely different questions. A rights issue asks existing shareholders to put in more; a private placement brings identified new investors on to the cap table. This guide explains each route, sets them side by side, walks through the private placement process, and reflects what actually happens in practice: most fresh issues are done as private placements.
- Rights issue
- Section 62(1)(a): new shares to existing shareholders, in proportion to holdings.
- Private placement
- Section 42: shares to a select group of identified persons, including new investors.
- Valuation report
- Not needed for a rights issue; required from a registered valuer for private placement.
- Offer letter
- No PAS-4 for a rights issue; PAS-4 mandatory for private placement.
- Key ROC filing
- Private placement needs PAS-3 within 15 days of allotment before funds can be used.
1 Rights issue: raising from existing shareholders
A rights issue is governed by Section 62(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 2013. The company offers new Equity Shares to its existing shareholders in proportion to their current holding, so that everyone gets the chance to keep their percentage intact. A shareholder can take up the offer, let it lapse, or renounce it in favour of someone else if the offer permits.
Because the shares go to people who are already members, the process is lighter. There is no PAS-4 offer letter and no registered valuer’s report, since you are not pricing an issue to outsiders. The core steps are a board resolution, a letter of offer to existing members giving them at least the minimum notice window to accept, allotment on the board’s approval, and updating the register of members and share certificates or demat records.
2 Private placement: bringing in new investors
A private placement is governed by Section 42 of the Companies Act, 2013, read with the related rules. The company offers securities to a select group of identified persons, which is how you bring a new angel, family office or fund on to the cap table. This is the route almost every priced fundraising uses, and it comes with a defined set of formalities that exist to keep private issues transparent.
- PAS-4 offer letter: a private placement offer cum application letter, issued only to the named, identified investors approved by the members.
- Valuation report: the price must be justified by a report from a registered valuer, since you are issuing to new investors.
- Separate bank account: all application money must come into a separate bank account opened for the issue, and only through banking channels, never in cash.
- No allotment before money: you cannot allot shares before the subscription money has actually hit that account.
- PAS-3 within 15 days: the return of allotment in Form PAS-3 must be filed with the Registrar of Companies within 15 days of allotment, and funds cannot be utilised until it is filed.
3 The two routes side by side
Set against each other, the choice usually makes itself once you know who is investing.
| Feature | Rights issue (Sec 62) | Private placement (Sec 42) |
|---|---|---|
| Who can subscribe | Existing shareholders only | Identified new or existing investors |
| Offer letter | Letter of offer to members (no PAS-4) | PAS-4 to named investors |
| Valuation report | Not required | Required from a registered valuer |
| Separate bank account | Not mandated | Mandatory; banking channel only |
| Allotment timing | On board approval after offer period | Only after money hits the account |
| Key ROC filing | PAS-3 (return of allotment) | PAS-3 within 15 days, before using funds |
| Best for | Existing members adding capital | Onboarding a new investor at a set price |
Brewly is raising ₹3 crore. A new fund is leading ₹2.5 crore of it, and an existing angel wants to add ₹50 lakh. Because the fund is a new investor, the whole priced round runs as a private placement under Section 42: PAS-4 to both named investors, a registered valuer’s report to fix the price, money into a separate account, and PAS-3 within 15 days of allotment. Brewly could technically have taken the existing angel’s ₹50 lakh via a rights issue, but running one clean Section 42 process for the full round is far simpler than splitting it.
4 Why private placement is the practical default
On paper the rights issue looks easier, and it is, but it only works when the money is coming from people already on your cap table. In real fundraising, the whole point is usually to bring in new capital: an angel, a micro-VC, a fund. New investors cannot be served through a rights issue, so the route defaults to private placement. In practice, most fresh issues a growing company does are private placements.
5 The private placement process, step by step
Once you know it is a Section 42 issue, the sequence is well defined. Run it in order and the closing is clean.
6 Your fundraising compliance checklist
- Decide the route by who is investing: existing members only means a rights issue can work; a new investor means private placement.
- For a private placement, obtain a registered valuer’s report before pricing the offer.
- Pass the required board and shareholder resolutions, and finalise the identified-investor list.
- Issue PAS-4 only to the named investors; never to anyone outside the approved list.
- Open a separate bank account and take money only through banking channels, never cash.
- Do not allot shares until the subscription money has actually landed in that account.
- File PAS-3 within 15 days of allotment, and do not use the funds until it is filed.
- If a non-resident invests, complete the FEMA FC-GPR filing and confirm FEMA pricing compliance.
Closing a round and unsure which route applies?
The wrong route, a missed valuation, or a late PAS-3 can hold up your money and your cap table. Talk to us about running your issue cleanly, from board resolutions to the ROC and FEMA filings.
Get help with my raise7 FAQs
What is the difference between a rights issue and a private placement?
Do you need a valuation report for a rights issue?
What is the PAS-4 in a private placement?
What is the deadline to file PAS-3 after a private placement?
Why do most private companies use private placement instead of a rights issue?
Related guides
Startup fundraising in India: the complete guide →
Startup India Seed Fund Scheme (SISFS) guide →
FEMA & FDI compliance for startups →
Share transfer in a Pvt Ltd company (SH-4) →
AS | Founder, CFOmatrix | Finance Strategy & Compliance CFOmatrix helps Indian startups build finance, tax and compliance functions that stand up to investor due diligence, from process and controls to the filings and the numbers behind them. |
Disclaimer: This article is general information as of September 2026 and is not legal or tax advice. The Companies Act, its rules and FEMA provisions can change. Confirm the current forms, timelines and thresholds with a qualified professional before issuing shares.